Shopify Theme Comparison: 9 Theme Store Themes Compared
Summarize this article with AI
Pops, Shapes, Wonder, Impulse, Release, Be Yours, Symmetry, Cama or Horizon: price, reviews, theme blocks and best fit for 9 Shopify Theme Store themes.
The Shopify Theme Store lists 292 paid themes, close to 1,300 listings once you count their presets. This Shopify theme comparison puts the Theme Store themes we have reviewed on a single page: their price, their reviews, whether they support theme blocks, and the kind of store each one suits.
We stick to the Theme Store. Shopify reviews every theme there (performance, accessibility, code), you can try it free with your own products for as long as you like, it updates from your Shopify admin, and you pay for it once. Our guide to choosing the best theme on the Shopify Theme Store covers these guarantees in detail.
Each matchup below has a summary and, where one exists, a link to the full comparison. When a matchup does not have its own article yet, we cover it here.
Disclosure: we build Pops and Cama, two of the themes in this comparison. Prices and reviews come from the Shopify Theme Store listings, checked in October 2026. When another theme is the better pick, we say so.
The short answer
- You are starting on a small budget: Horizon, free, built by Shopify on theme blocks.
- You sell food, drinks or cosmetics: Pops ($400) or Shapes ($420).
- You have a large catalog or run a lot of promotions: Impulse ($500) or Symmetry ($420), two proven Theme Store picks.
- You want the most conversion features built into the theme: Release ($420).
- You want a conversion theme with built-in quizzes and subscriptions: Wonder ($390), 99% positive reviews.
- You sell beauty products: Cama ($240), the theme we build for beauty brands.
Compare Shopify themes side by side
Prices are in US dollars, paid once. You can try every one of these themes free in your store and only pay when you publish it.
Theme (developer) | Price | Positive reviews | Theme blocks | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Pops (Trafik Plus) | $400 | In review, no reviews yet | Yes, with Group block | Food, drink and beauty brands |
Shapes (Switch Themes) | $420 | 99% of 86 | No | Food, drink and beauty brands |
Wonder (Nethype) | $390 | 99% of 149 | No | Conversion-focused stores, quizzes and subscriptions |
Impulse (Archetype Themes) | $500 | 94% of 1,304 | No | Promotions, mid-size catalogs |
Release (DigiFist) | $420 | 95% of 118 | No | Conversion-focused stores |
Be Yours (RoarTheme) | $350 | 98% of 695 | No | Beauty brands |
Symmetry (Clean Canvas) | $420 | 94% of 392 | No | Large catalogs |
Cama (Trafik Plus) | $240 | 86% of 7 | No | Beauty and DTC brands on a tight budget |
Horizon (Shopify) | Free | 36% of 212 | Yes, with Group block | Getting started, building with blocks |
Shopify theme comparisons, matchup by matchup
Pops vs Shapes
Two colorful themes for CPG brands, $20 apart ($400 vs $420). Pops includes a bundle builder, cart upsells, a shareable cart link, a countdown timer and stories, and it is built on theme blocks. Shapes, released in 2022 and rated 99% positive across 86 reviews, keeps the edge on ingredient blocks, comparison scales, recently viewed products and breadcrumbs.
Read the full Pops vs Shapes comparison
Pops vs Impulse
Impulse, by Archetype Themes, is one of the most installed themes on the Theme Store: 94% positive across 1,304 reviews(opens in a new tab), for $500. It is designed for stores that live on promotions, with a cart drawer, cross-selling, a stock counter, a countdown timer, a mega menu and promo pop-ups.
Pops costs $100 less and goes further on two points. It is built on theme blocks with a Group block, while the Impulse listing only talks about sections. And it includes a bundle builder, which the Impulse feature list does not mention, so you would need an app for it. Impulse has years of reviews and a large base of stores behind it; Pops, still in review, has no reviews yet.
- Choose Impulse if you have a mid-size catalog, run a lot of promotions and want a theme proven by thousands of stores.
- Choose Pops if you sell bundles or boxes, want to build your pages with blocks and lean on a colorful brand identity.
Pops vs Release
Release, by DigiFist, ticks the most conversion boxes in this comparison for $420: a cart drawer, a sticky add-to-cart button, quantity pricing for B2B, a stock counter and a countdown timer. It has 95% positive reviews across 118 and suits a store that wants all of these tools in the theme without worrying much about visual identity.
Pops costs $20 less and takes the other side: a branded store, colorful and animated, built with theme blocks, with a built-in bundle and box builder to raise average order value. Choose Release for feature coverage, Pops for a CPG brand that wants to stand out.
Pops vs Wonder
Wonder, by Nethype, is one of the best-rated themes on the Theme Store: $390 and 99% positive across 149 reviews. It is built by a Shopify Plus agency with three Awwwards to its name. It is a conversion-focused theme: a slide-out and sticky cart, cross-selling, a countdown timer, a stock counter, and, built into the theme, bundles, product quizzes and a subscription widget. It ships with translations for EU languages.
Pops costs $10 more and shares some of these tools: bundles, cart upsells, a countdown timer. The difference is how you build pages. Pops is built entirely on theme blocks, with the Group block, while Wonder is not on our list of Shopify themes that use theme blocks. Choose Wonder for an all-round conversion theme that is already well rated, with quizzes and subscriptions. Choose Pops for a food, drink or beauty brand that wants a colorful, animated identity and to build its pages with blocks.
Pops vs Horizon, the free theme
Horizon(opens in a new tab) is free, built by Shopify, and also runs on theme blocks with a Group block; Shopify Magic can even generate a block from a description. For a new store, it is the best free starting point, even though its Theme Store reviews are harsh: 36% positive across 212.
What Pops adds for $400: a bundle and box builder, cart upsells, a shareable cart link, a countdown timer, stories, and motion effects (falling products, cursor trail, Lottie animations, animated headings) you set up from blocks. If your brand lives on color and bundles, Pops replaces one or two apps you pay for every month; if not, Horizon is enough.
See also the list of Shopify themes that use theme blocks.
Be Yours, Symmetry and Cama at a glance
Be Yours (RoarTheme, $350) is the best-rated theme in this comparison: 98% positive across 695 reviews. Its demo opens on a countdown timer, handy for launches and flash sales.
Symmetry (Clean Canvas, $420) has 94% positive reviews across 392. It is a safe pick for a large catalog with many collections to show.
Cama ($240), which we build, is the cheapest paid theme in this comparison. It targets beauty brands and DTC brands starting out on a tight budget. It has 86% positive reviews, from only 7 reviews so far.
Which theme to choose for your store
- Beverage brand: our top 5 Shopify themes for beverage brands.
- Matcha or tea brand: the best Shopify themes for matcha brands.
- Food or CPG brand: the best Shopify themes for food brands.
- Small budget: the best Shopify themes for small businesses.
- Conversion first: 8 paid Shopify themes judged on CRO.
- Building pages with blocks: Shopify themes that use theme blocks.
Pops: the theme we build for CPG brands
Pops is the latest theme from Trafik Plus, a Shopify Theme Store partner since 2022. It is made for DTC and CPG brands that sell what you eat, drink or put on your face, and that want a store that looks like them rather than one more blank template.
- Three presets: Pops (energy drinks), Lueur (makeup and skincare) and Scoop (protein cereal).
- Bundles without an app: box builder, cart upsells and a shareable cart link.
- Theme blocks with a Group block: build a layout once and reuse it across the store.
- Motion: falling-content physics, cursor trail, Lottie, animated headings and stories.
- $400 one-time payment, with free updates from your Shopify admin.
Pops is currently in review by the Shopify Theme Store team, so it is not on sale yet. Its documentation(opens in a new tab) is already available in English and French.
What about themes sold outside the Theme Store?
Shrine and Elixir are not in this comparison: they are sold on their developer's own site, without Shopify's review, and you pay once with no free trial and no refunds. Subscription themes such as Story and FullStack follow the same model. We reviewed the first two separately:
Frequently asked questions
What is the best Shopify theme?
No single theme is best for every store. Horizon is the best free starting point; Impulse and Symmetry are safe picks for large catalogs; Pops and Shapes suit food, drink and beauty brands. Start from your catalog and your budget, then try two or three themes with your own products.
Should I choose a free or a paid Shopify theme?
A free theme like Horizon is enough to get started. A paid theme, roughly $150 to $500 one-time on the Theme Store, includes more features, which saves you from apps billed every month.
Can I try a Shopify theme before buying it?
Yes, for every Theme Store theme: “Try theme” adds it to your store with no time limit and no credit card, and you only pay when you publish it.
Is Pops available on the Shopify Theme Store?
Not yet. Pops is in review by the Shopify Theme Store team, with no launch date. Once it is live, you will install it from the Theme Store with “Try theme” and only pay when you publish it.

Keep reading
Enterprise Shopify Theme Review (2026): Price, Pros, Cons and Alternatives
Our Enterprise Shopify theme review: $420 price, 113 merchant reviews, speed tests, updates, and a comparison with Symmetry, Impulse and Pops.
Shopify Page Builder in 2026: Is It Worth It? 10 Apps Compared With Real Data
Is a Shopify page builder worth it? We priced 10 apps over three years and read 295 one- and two-star reviews to find out when a builder pays off, and when your theme is enough.
Elixir Shopify Theme Review (2026): Price, Pros, Cons and a Theme Store Alternative
An honest Elixir Shopify theme review: $200 price, licences, refunds, V2 and code, compared with Pops, a Theme Store alternative built on theme blocks.
